AdvertiseDonate
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Headlines from coast to coast.
World Press Post · 150 South Wacker Drive, #2400, Chicago, IL 60606

Knesset bill limits conversion recognition

A new proposal would restrict the Law of Return to halachic conversions, reversing a 2021 High Court ruling that accepted Reform and Conservative rites.

By Ricardo Brooks ·

Illustration for: Knesset bill limits conversion recognition
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The Otzma Yehudit party submitted a bill to the 26th Knesset two days after its swearing-in, seeking to limit the Law of Return to conversions performed strictly according to halacha. This legislative move directly targets the Dahan ruling from 2021, in which a nine-justice panel of the High Court of Justice determined that the state must recognize Reform and Conservative conversions for immigration and registry purposes.

MK Limor Son Har-Melech introduced the draft, which redefines a Jew as someone born to a Jewish mother who does not belong to another faith, or someone who converted under halachic law. Sponsors argue this represents a valid exercise of legislative sovereignty, citing former Supreme Court President Esther Hayut, who noted the Knesset could redefine conversion through future laws.

The bill leaves the term halacha undefined, creating ambiguity over which authority determines compliance. The Chief Rabbinate and private Orthodox courts both hold potential jurisdiction. This distinction matters because private initiatives like Giyur K'Halacha convert approximately 220 people annually. That figure is comparable to the Reform movement's 234 conversions per year and higher than the Conservative movement's 92.

The proposal would alter how conversions performed abroad are treated. The High Court has recognized Diaspora Reform and Conservative conversions for registry purposes since the late 1980s. An analysis by the Israel Democracy Institute states the bill would remove aliyah eligibility for those converted overseas. Pew Research Center data shows only 9% of Jewish adults in the United States identify as Orthodox, while 37% are Reform and 17% are Conservative.

Lawmakers have historically avoided adding the phrase according to halacha to the Law of Return to prevent friction with Diaspora Jewry. In 1970, following the Shalit ruling, the Knesset included a definition of a Jew but skipped that specific wording. Prime ministers from both the Right and Left have resisted such changes for over 50 years. In the final days of the previous Knesset, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu blocked an identical proposal from MK Simcha Rothman.

The bill retains the grandchild clause, allowing individuals with a Jewish grandparent to immigrate as family members, though they would not be registered as Jewish. Those with non-Orthodox conversions and no other qualifying relatives could lose their right to immigrate. The High Court ruling affected an average of 326 Reform and Conservative converts annually in Israel, a small fraction of those converting through state or military systems.

MK Simcha Rothman stated the intention is not to harm liberal Judaism but to prevent fictitious or lenient conversions conducted for immigration. Supporters argue the bill unifies Jewish religious law by preventing the state from recognizing individuals who cannot marry or be buried under Chief Rabbinate rules.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get World Press Post in your inboxHeadlines from coast to coast. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get World Press Post in your inboxHeadlines from coast to coast. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.