AdvertiseDonate
Thursday, November 19, 2026
Headlines from coast to coast.
World Press Post · 150 South Wacker Drive, #2400, Chicago, IL 60606

Court upholds firing of truck driver over smartglasses use at gas terminal

A federal circuit court judge ruled that Ricardo Martins Silva's dismissal from Toll Transport was justified after he photographed an LPG site with wearable tech.

By Olga Menon ·

Illustration for: Court upholds firing of truck driver over smartglasses use at gas terminal
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Ricardo Martins Silva has lost his legal challenge against Toll Transport after a federal circuit court judge upheld his dismissal for using smartglasses at a gas terminal in Victoria. Justice Karl Blake ruled last week that the incident was objectively serious, marking the first reported case in Australia where a worker was fired specifically for using such devices in a workplace.

The dispute began on 17 June 2025, when Silva, an LPG tanker driver who had worked for Toll Transport for eight months, complained about excessive vibration in a truck assigned to him. He was advised to choose a different vehicle. Silva then went to the Long Island Point terminal in Hastings, operated by Origin Energy, and used his smartglasses to take photographs of the equipment. He sent these images to a supervisor, stating he was returning the truck to Dandenong and leaving because no time remained for deliveries that day.

An Esso terminal worker notified Toll that any electrical equipment on-site was considered intrinsically unsafe due to the risk of sparks causing an explosion. Origin Energy subsequently requested that Silva be removed from work, citing his attitude and the missed planned deliveries. Between 17 and 19 June, Silva emailed his concerns about his role and safety conditions before formally lodging a complaint on 20 June.

Toll stood Silva down on 22 June. At a meeting on 24 June, the company described the glasses incident as a critical safety breach warranting a formal investigation. By 30 June, the company decided to suspend him due to the seriousness of the event. On 9 July, Silva was informed that the device use violated the company code of practice and his contract, leading to his termination on 18 July.

Silva argued his dismissal breached the Fair Work Act, claiming it was retaliation for his prior complaints. In his defense, he wrote to his employer that unresolved trauma from a truck fire in March 2025 affected his judgment. He also noted he had attempted to mitigate risks by covering his smartglasses with safety glasses.

Justice Blake found that Silva was plainly aware of the risks and conceded during cross-examination that he knew he had done the wrong thing. The court determined the dismissal was because he wore the smartglasses at the terminal, not because of his complaints, and dismissed the application.

The ruling arrives as local councils across Australia ban smartglasses in public spaces like gyms and pools. The federal government is also considering bans in government offices to manage privacy implications associated with devices like Meta’s Ray-Bans and the Kmart Anko brand.

More News · World news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get World Press Post in your inboxHeadlines from coast to coast. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get World Press Post in your inboxHeadlines from coast to coast. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.